James Wagenseller, Army P: the 2026 season story
James Wagenseller is a punter for Army (American Athletic). He ranks 11th of 232 punters in Division I by the Player Index, which judges every punter on the measures that matter at the position, adjusted for the opponents he faced.
Scouting report
Why it matters. Every measure is set against every ranked punter, so a strength here is a strength against the whole position, not just his own team. James Wagenseller's strongest measure is gross punt average at 48.2, 7th of 134 (the average is 43.6). His weakest is touchbacks at 7%, 92nd of 134 (the average is 6%).
Against every punter
Why it matters. Volume, efficiency and impact plays can tell different stories: a player can be busy without being effective, or rarely used but dangerous every time. Among ranked punters he sits, on average, in the 63rd percentile for efficiency and 50th for impact.
The season, game by game
Why it matters. Consistency matters to a team: one huge game and five quiet ones is a different season from six solid ones. Over 9 games, James Wagenseller's best came in week 10 against Air Force and his quietest in week 7 against Florida Atlantic.
Where he does his damage
Why it matters. The shape of a player's production, not just its size, is what opponents scout.
National and conference
Why it matters. The Player Index puts every punter on one scale, adjusted for the defenses or offenses he faced, so a rank here is comparable across conferences. James Wagenseller is 10th of 134 FBS punters and 1st of 14 in the American Athletic. Next up nationally is Will Duncan of Air Force, 0.02 ahead on the index.
Career
Why it matters. A player's track record is the best guide to whether a season like this one is likely to last. This is his best season by the Player Index so far, out of 3 we have.
Punters like him
Why it matters. Players with similar profiles tend to be used the same way, which makes them a quick way to picture his game. His closest match this season is Hunter Green of Washington.
